1856 OC-1
Mispunched 6 - Top-30 Variety (early die state only)

Die Pair 1 - A
Date Grid RE / 4-3.0 / Level
Obverse Die States a, b
Estimated Rarity R2
1, 6 Vertical C, VSL
Reverse Die States a, b, c, d



Comments:
   This is the only use of Obverse 1 and the only use of Reverse A.


Obverse P1

The photo below shows the Obverse 1 attribution grid.



1856 Obverse 1 Attribution Grid

This is the only business strike obverse die. Its unique features make it easy to attribute, although the date position is very similar to the proof obverse. The next photo expands to show the repunching on the 6.



1856 Obverse 1 Repunched 6

For many years this repunching was considered to be an overdate, 6/4. This was primarily because most examples show only the line in the upper loop of the 6, which appears to be the diagonal of an underlying 4. Only early die states, such as the one pictured, show the repunching to the left of the lower loop of the 6. We showed in an article in the Gobrecht Journal (reference 11) that this repunching is actually an underlying 6, which was first punched at a 45 degree angle, then corrected to its final position. Early die states, which show all the elements of the underdigit seen in the photo, are rare, probably less than 10% of the surviving examples of the date, at least R5. Also note in the second photo the diagonal die lines extending up to the left from the denticles. These are seen on the rare early die states but not on the normally seen mid- to late-die-state examples. We’ve included this early die state as one of our Top-30 varieties.


Obverse 1 Die States
  1. Perfect Die. The underlying 6 is fully visible, as in the previous photo. This die state is rare. We've only seen a small number of examples.
  2. The die has been polished. The diagonal die lines extending from the denticles below the date are gone. Only the diagonal line within the upper loop of the final 6 is visible to indicate the repunching.
No later die states have been observed.


Reverse A

1856 Reverse A features several markers that allow easy identification. The most obvious is a large lump that extends into the field from near the top of the curve of the left wing. Other smaller lumps are visible farther down the edge of the wing. These are shown in the following photo.



Reverse A Lump on Eagle's Left Wing

In the state that’s usually seen this reverse displays numerous die cracks. Some of these are shown in the following photo.



Reverse A Die Cracks


Reverse A Die States
  1. Perfect Die.
  2. Very faint die cracks across the top of UNITED STATES.
  3. The die cracks are heavier and completely surround the reverse.
  4. The die cracks are heavier. This is the state shown in the previous photo.
The first two states are rare. We’ve seen only one coin with die state a. For both states a and b the obverse exhibits the complete repunched 6 described previously. For state c and d the only repunching visible is the line in the upper loop of the 6. At least 90% of the examples of OC-1 are reverse states c or d. Most examples seen exhibit about 5 degrees counterclockwise die rotation. We've seen one late die state with unrotated dies.



Photo credits:

Obverse 1 and Reverse A:   1856 ANACS AU58, from the Osburn-Cushing reference collection.
Reverse A die cracks:   1856 PCGS AU55, from the Osburn-Cushing reference collection.


Copyright © 2015, by Dick Osburn and Brian Cushing, All rights reserved.